Antique Georgian silver sugar tongs

Thomas Ollivant was a Manchester maker, although his mark was registered in London.  These sugar tongs are interesting for the following reason.

 

Thomas Ollivant registered as a Plate-worker in London in May 1789.  It is believed that he was more of a retailer than a Plate-worker, buying London stock for resale, probably in Manchester.  "Touching Gold & Silver", a catalogue of an exhibition at Goldsmith's hall in November 1978 discusses a cream jug with Thomas Ollivant's marks over-striking Peter & Jonathan Bateman marks.  It therefore seems that Thomas Ollivant bought silver from the Bateman workshops and over-struck his own mark before selling the item.

 

bullet

For all 4 pairs of tongs, the maker's mark is over-struck on top of another mark.

bullet

With the first & second pairs, the mark underneath looks extremely like it could be Hester Bateman's mark

bullet

Notice the overall style of the tongs and the similarity with Hester Bateman's work.

 

My theory is therefore that Thomas Ollivant bought these tongs from Hester Bateman, over-struck with his own mark and then sold them.  Perhaps more tongs will come to light, showing the Thomas Ollivant mark over-struck on a Bateman mark, or even the mark of another maker.  Has anyone seen a pair of Thomas Ollivant tongs where the maker's mark is NOT over-struck?

 

Richard Evans of Shrewsbury is another provincial maker who appeared to have done the same.

 

Anyone want to offer any comment?  tongtwister@silversugartongs.com.

To see the maker's marks click on the picture below:

 

1786-1790

A pair of flared, bright cut tongs that look exactly like any other Hester Bateman tongs

notive the mark is overstruck - as usual!

1786-1790

A really crude monogram - not likely to be of the period

Very clearly over-struck - Hester Bateman?

1786-1790

Over-struck - but cannot see the original maker

1791-1792

Very off-centre, with signs of a previous erasure

Note the similarity of style with the other pair

Also clearly overstruck.